Zaryi wrote:
Usd, so if you're out and see a woman dressed 'sluttily', you're not at fautl for raping her? You think it's justified just to pass of your crime by just waving a hand and accusing her of dressing like she asked for it?
Usd blames style of dress. I think that's off-base.
Clothing is a personal statement. Certain kinds of people make certain kinds of statements.
There is no causal relationship between a style of dress and getting raped.
There is a causal relationship between a certain kind of person, who dresses a certain way, then either gets raped or makes such an accusation.
Women who dress like sluts do it because they want a certain kind of attention. That same drive makes them do other things to seek attention. If a woman dresses like a slut, she's probably also going to put herself in compromising positions.
There is a difference between walking to your car at night and getting jumped and raped - which, although it happens, is very rare - or some other brazen crime of that nature...and seeking the attention of young and borderline males by dressing in a slutty way then attending events late at night, where there are charged passions, confused situations, and large numbers of people in close quarters - and some of those people aren't entirely stable.
Zaryi wrote:
It's funny, when I went to Seattle's SlutWalk there were sEveral women who'd been raped, and wore what the clothing they had been rape in. Despite being incredibly modest, all of tem had xperiencdx victim blaming/shamig, one had even been harasse of of her dorm at the UW, and this was in the 70s.
This is bullshit for two reasons:
1) Women who are really the victims of rape aren't going to run around talking about it. It's shameful, not because of "misplaced social victimization" or "being seen as a slut" but because anyone who's been violated in any way - whether it's rape, or any other sort of violation - feels shame to have been taken advantage of. That feeling is human, and it is neither wrong nor useless.
Fear of shame at having been violated is a positive moral force. Constructively channelled, it guides one to find assertiveness and responsibility.
If one does not feel that shame...it is because being violated was never part of the equation in the first place. Such is human nature.
2) The very act of showing up to something called SlutWalk as a purported rape victim is drawing that association for oneself - between dressing like a sex object, and being used as one.
So who's making the argument that women
are sex objects?
The rapists, the women going about their business (or have been taken advantage of), or the women who claim to have been raped then associate with sluts?
Zaryi wrote:
SlutWalk is a movement to (first and foremost) and the culture of victim blaming.
No. It is a movement for and of the "I want it both ways. I want responsibility, empowerment and protection under the law - everything that comes with being seen as equal to men - but I also want all the prerogatives and influence that come with displaying my sexual allure and behaving in a compromising manner".
Weena wrote:
It's a shame you were brutally assaulted, but... well you shouldn't have left yourself open.
There is a difference between,
"I parked my Beemer, which I am very proud of, in the parking garage, because I was doing an errand, and someone broke in."
and
"I parked my Beemer, which I am very proud of, in a troubled neighborhood, because I wanted even more attention, and someone broke in."
Crime A deserves sympathy. Crime B deserves contempt.
Azelma wrote:
Women should all have rape whistles and should take mandatory self defense classes.
This, too, is an immature attitude.
These sorts of things are ways women attempt to "empower" themselves to compensate for the inherent contradictions and unreality of their preferred lifestyle.
Following your analogy - which I also made - relying on self defense and whistles to get out of a bad situation is no different than doing what you described, putting oneself in a compromising situation, then carrying a marine air horn and a Glock and thinking that will solve your problems.
...No. The solution is to grow up, accept that life is a series of choices, and not put oneself in compromising situations.